Gerard Adlum |   13 minutes reading time | Dec 7, 2018 3:19:51 PM

What life is really like as an Amazon FBA seller

If you were to believe the online hype, you could easily think that making money through Fulfilled by Amazon is a doddle.

I mean, all you have to do is create a few listings, send goods to an Amazon warehouse once in a while, answer the odd customer query and watch the money roll in, right?

For every seller who swears blindly that FBA is the best business decision they have ever made, however, I can guarantee you that there’s another ten who deeply regret it.

By no means do I want to discourage every seller out there, but people should be aware of what it really takes to make FBA work.

Spoiler: It’s really not as “hands-off” as some would have you believe.

The fees quickly become penalties
You possibly can’t afford to go FBA.

Online selling is a margins game and FBA is going to take a slice out of yours. If you’re already struggling to make the percentages work for you, then FBA isn’t going to change that.

Below is the basic formula for how Amazon calculates what you owe.

How FBA fees are calculated


Now, the first part of that is pretty straightforward. In fact, your per unit fulfillment fee may very well be less than it would if you were looking after it yourself. Amazon has built up an incredible web of logistics partners that allows it to keep costs down.


There are no real qualms here. Factor this fulfillment fee into the selling price, which you’d be doing anyway, and you’re fine.


It’s the storage fees that can really hurt sellers, however. You can find precise info on the U.S. fees here. U.K. based sellers should go here.


Here’s the simplest way of putting things; if you have products sitting too long at an Amazon warehouse then you are going to pay through the nose for them.


If from experience or research you know there are certain SKUs in your inventory that don’t sell quickly then I’d recommend you steer clear of using FBA for them.


FBA isn’t going to work for everyone on the marketplace. But then again, it’s not designed to.


Traditionally, the items that work best for FBA tend to be small (in terms of both weight and dimensions). I’m not saying outright that over-sized goods should be disregarded entirely, but you could very easily find yourself with a hefty storage fee to pay a few months down the line.




 FBA horror storiesSeller beware! The FBA horror stories

If you want to scare yourself out of the idea of using FBA at all, just go onto the Amazon Seller Central forum. There are countless unhappy merchants disappointed with some aspect of the service.


If you really want to give yourself sleepless nights, however, you simply have to read about this one. The "too long; didn't read version" is that a seller with a 97% positive rating and a thriving business lost everything overnight through no fault of their own. Seller beware.


It's enough to send shivers down the spine of even the most hard-nosed trader. Bare in mind though that it took place in 2012 and you would hope that Amazon has improved its order processing since then (not guaranteed though!).  It is still a cautionary tale about putting your stock in the hands of a third-party, even one as celebrated as Amazon. 



Why do bad things happen to good sellers?

That's a fair question. It's reasonable to expect that a company the size of Amazon at the very least  shouldn't be sending out the wrong orders. To explain why this happens, you need to understand how FBA works behind the scenes.


Have you heard the term "co-mingled"? Basically, by default, Amazon lumps all of the same products into the one storage bin in its warehouse. Yep, you read that right. It doesn't matter where in the world it originally came from. Amazon might even have some of their own stock in there too for good measure. It does this in order to speed up the selection process. 


So when a customer places an order for a certain product though your listing, they aren't necessarily going to receive one that you supplied to Amazon. Here's one example of how that can affect sellers negatively. There are, unfortunately, a whole lot more.  If you're interested, there's a thread on Seller Central that covers ways of avoiding co-mingling.



What can you do if you think you’ve been hard done by?

As an Amazon seller, you have got to know your rights and entitlements down to the smallest details. Sure, it’s Amazon’s world and you are only renting space there, but you still have recourse to correct injustices.


You can open a case with Amazon, outlining the error as you see it, supported by as much documentation as possible.


Sellers may need to argue their case with Amazon

Usually, Amazon will cover the cost of FBA returns, though not always. They may try to pass on the cost to you.


Be prepared to stand your ground. But sometimes, it’s best just to lick your wounds and move on.




How the top sellers makes FBA work

I spoke to Amazon marketplace expert Shannon Roddy ( to get his perspective on the value of FBA and how to make it work for you.


“With over 300 million Amazon Customers and 100 million Prime Members, FBA is becoming more and more critical to success.


Free 2-Day Shipping. Prime members spend 2-3 times more than non-prime members, so if your products aren't Prime eligible, a majority of those customers won't even see your products in their search results.


The two biggest proactive steps sellers can take to minimize FBA fees are:


1) Optimize Packaging

This means working to minimize the volume weight that Amazon charges sellers by, including the use of poly-bagging smaller products instead of using large boxes.


2) Forecast Sales

The more accurately a seller can predict their future sales based on calculations including time of year, sales, promotions, etc, the more they can reduce their monthly inventory fees and long-term storage fees that Amazon is known for charging.


If sellers have distribution centers or warehouses that can leverage Seller Fulfilled Prime, they can potentially take advantage of lower fees, but it requires concise inventory management, timely shipping and uploading tracking to comply with Amazon's strict metrics. 


Regardless of the size of any seller, it's important to determine which products make sense for FBA and figure out how to maximize sales of their best selling products using Amazon fulfillment.


Sellers that add FBA tend to see at minimum a 20% increase in sales almost immediately. For sellers who are limited by how many units they can send into FBA, it is beneficial to set up dual fulfillment, that is an FBA and FBM listing on each ASIN so that if their FBA inventory happens to sell out they can still continue selling the item merchant fulfilled”.


Shannon makes some really good points here. I particularly think it’s worth highlighting his last comment regarding the mix of FBA and FBM for the same ASIN. 


The most successful sellers often mix and match their fulfillment strategy depending on the product type, demand and competition. Not every product in your inventory has to be FBA. 


New call-to-action


The common FBA Mistakes that sellers make

FBA expert Phil Masiello ( was also able to provide me with some excellent insight into some of the common errors he sees sellers making on a daily basis.


"There are three main pitfalls that I see FBA sellers make continually that affect their overall performance in the long term.



They forget about their brand
Yes, you are selling on Amazon and yes it is their platform. But in the end, you want the customer to know who you, the seller are. Create your own products under your own brand. This is not a difficult achievement in this day and age.


You can register a trademark on the USPTO directly without the need of an attorney and you can use any number of crowd sourcing sites to develop a logo and brand image. This provides more control over profitability and growth.

Being a re-seller of other brands is not a long term profitable strategy unless you have a supply chain advantage. When you look at the big re-sellers on Amazon, they are all tied to a major distributor or wholesaler.


When you do not own the product page and are just another seller on someone else’s listing you are vulnerable. The only advantage is price. If others have a better cost advantage on the product, then you will win the buy box infrequently. Especially if it is a high velocity item. Playing the online arbitrage game of trying to find product cheap in one channel and sell them on another is a lot of work for a small profit.


Building a brand will connect the customers to you for the long term and create customer retention and long term value. Just look at Tuft & Needle. They started out selling mattresses on Amazon and created their own brand that spans multi channels.


Tuft & Needle started out on Amazon but created a strong brand




They don't make use of the tool Amazon provides 

I meet far too many sellers who are enamored with finding a great tool to help them. Most of these tools are just harvesting information that is already in your account. The best place to find relevant target search terms is in your advertising reports for example.  Also, Amazon collects and reports your sales tax. Its built into your account.


What sellers should be focused on is getting into the brand registry. This enables sellers to create a storefront that allows the use of video, images and expanded content to discuss what you are all about. The registry also provides the use of Enhanced Brand content product pages, similar to A+ pages on Vendor Central. Inclusion in the registry also enhances your campaign manager, providing more tools for advertising.


Email your buyers through your selling account. There is no better way to get more ratings, build a brand and develop loyalty than with communication. Also, this is a great way to stop a negative review before it becomes one. The buyers now have a way to speak with you, the seller.

They don't fully understand Amazon Marketing Services
Stop treating Amazon ad campaigns as if they were Adwords. It is not the same. Amazon campaigns get more efficient the more optimized your product pages are. The best way to lower your ACoS (advertising cost of sale/spend) is with optimizing pages. Make sure that the Targets you are selecting in ads match up to what you have on your product pages.


Pull your advertising reports each week, use the information they are providing and make changes to your ads and your product pages. There is no information more valuable than these reports on Amazon.


Amazon Marketing Services

In the database side of a product page, you cannot use your competitors name or brands in any search term fields. But you can on the ad side. So build ads to target your competition.


Your ad reports are telling you the exact competitors product ASIN’s a customer was on when they saw your ad. That is great information to help you do a better job of targeting. When your pages are optimized, your CPC will be about 60% of the suggested bid for a targeted search term".


For me, the biggest takeaway from what Phil is saying is that sellers can't be totally reliant on Amazon to do all the work for them. For long term success, you need to be wholly focused on building your brand up to a point where you can survive without Amazon. Otherwise, you will always be at the mercy of policy changes, fee increases or as we discussed early, unfair bans or account closures.



Is FBA status essential to winning The Buy Box?

Whether you’re a seasoned Amazon seller, or you’re totally new to it, the Buy Box should still be your goal. 82% of shoppers never even look beyond that yellow box. It’s the key to a successful Amazon business.


We’ve written before about what it takes to win the Buy Box. It’s a relatively complicated formula, with a few different aspects to it. Mainly though, it comes down to price and fulfillment method.


FBA & The Amazon Buy Box



All other things being equal (price, product, country etc), in a battle between 2 or more merchants, the seller who is FBA will get nod.  For some commentators, FBA status matters more than price. So FBA sellers could in theory price higher than their rivals and still in the Buy Box.


Why? The cynics will say that it’s all part of Amazon’s masterplan to make signing up to their optional programs a necessity in order to survive on the marketplace.


Maybe they have a point, but officially the reason is that FBA guarantees customers prompt, reliable service. They are therefore more likely to make the purchase.


So yes, being FBA can help you win the Buy Box. That alone will be enough information for some sellers to join up. Again, I would urge caution though. If your products are otherwise better suited to self-fulfillment and if FBA would make it difficult for you to make a profit then resist the temptation. 



If you're the kind of seller that needs full visibility and transparency across every aspect of your business then you will find FBA incredibly frustrating.


There is potentially a place for it in your arsenal, but you have to have your eyes wide-open going into it. 


To begin, send a small amount of products to Amazon and test the waters. If they move quickly, and you are turning enough of profit from them then make a bigger commitment next time. Play it cautiously at first and gradually scale up.


eDesk is the only help desk purpose built for online sellers. It integrates with all of the major marketplaces and channels, saving you time, money and headaches. Start your free trial today.



Start my Free Trial


Start selling smarter today

Sell more with eDesk

Try now for free